Choose Your Own Salt Water Taffy37 Flavors, One Per Bag!
Craving that classic Cape Cod taffy experience? Now you can bring it home, one flavor at a time! With our Choose Your Own Salt Water Taffy collection, you get to pick your favorite flavor from a rainbow of 37 mouthwatering options, each chewy bite bursting with sweet, summery nostalgia. From fruity standouts like raspberry and watermelon, to creamy classics like vanilla and root beer, and even adventurous picks like orange pineapple or mango, theres something to satisfy every kind of sweet tooth.
Each order is hand-packed right here at our family-run shop on Cape Cod, where weve been sharing candy and smiles for over 40 years. Youll receive your selected flavor in your choice of a 10-piece sampler, 8-ounce bag, or 1-pound bag. Whether youre building a themed gift basket, planning a party favor, or simply treating yourself to a soft and stretchy seaside favorite, this taffy delivers that sun-soaked boardwalk feeling, no matter the season.
Please note: Each bag contains one flavor only. No mixed bags at this time, but with so many delicious flavors to try, why not grab a few?
Why Youll Love It
- 37 irresistible flavorsChoose from a wide variety of fruity, creamy, and unique taffy options – there’s a favorite for everyone.
- One flavor per bagGet exactly what you’re craving with a full bag of your top pick – no surprises, just sweet satisfaction.
- Cape Cod traditionPacked with nostalgic charm from our family-run candy shop in the heart of Cape Cod.
- Soft, chewy textureEach piece is delightfully stretchy and smooth, just the way real salt water taffy should be.
- Great for gifting or snackingAvailable in three sizes – perfect for party favors, stocking stuffers, or keeping your own stash stocked.
